Not many people will be happy to read this, but we’ve come to believe that most people post too much on X. Whilst it is commonly advised to post as much content as possible (multiple times a day), we believe that for most people, it’s best to post less. Here’s why, and what we’d recommend instead.
| The daily rule | What we argue for | |
|---|---|---|
| Replying and answering | When there is time left | Most days, about ten minutes |
| Publishing your own posts | Every day, several times if possible | When you have something to say, often 2 or 3 times a week |
| Measure of success | Did I post today? | Were my last ten posts worth reading? |
| Quiet weeks | A failure | Normal |
| Who it suits | News desks, support teams, people who enjoy it | Most individuals and small businesses |
Reasons to post less
Advice to post multiple times per day comes from people and businesses whose entire purpose is to post content on social media. They have teams, content to post, and therefore a need to post that content. But, when this advice is given to people outside of social media (plumbers, teachers, two person shops), there is no social media team, content to post, or reason to post. All that is left is “Post every day”. However, very rarely is the question asked “Does this person actually have anything to post everyday?”, and we believe that this question should be asked.
Posts can be poor quality
If you’re forced to post every day, you’ll inevitably post poor quality content. Poor quality content includes generic motivational posts on Mondays, random questions, and links with “Thoughts?” in the caption. Whilst individual pieces of content might not cause any issues, collectively they can teach your audience that your content isn’t worth stopping for. Once someone has started to fast scroll past your content, they will fast scroll past even your good content.
They may no longer follow you
It’s a nice gesture from someone to follow you, however this gesture can be reversed with just one click. We have unfollowed accounts we liked because we got fed up with them posting 8 times a day and dominating people’s feeds. We suspect you may have done too. However, we have never unfollowed an account because they posted useful content only twice a week.
It is tiring
Many of our friends have begun an account with great enthusiasm, and posted daily for 6 weeks. Eventually though, they get to a point where they feel slightly embarrassed that they’re no longer posting, and give up. However, they shouldn’t be! The problem was the frequency of posts, not the person. If someone posts twice a week for 3 years, they will be seen by vastly more people than if they post daily for 6 weeks, and then stop entirely.
Fair counter arguments
It is fair to argue that posting frequently means you improve quickly. Also, since you have very few followers when starting out, posting more means that you give yourself a higher chance of being seen. However, we believe that daily posting is not necessary. You can practice writing posts by writing in a notebook or replying to posts. Additionally, whilst a new account may struggle to be seen, getting good replies on other people’s posts will lead to your account being seen much more than posting regularly on your own feed (which will likely be seen by hardly anyone).
What we would do
We believe that it is important to distinguish between visibility and content creation. Visibility can be achieved by replying and responding to people, and we believe that this should be done on most days (it helps you become visible, and only takes 10mins). Content creation can be done by creating your own posts. We believe that this should only be done if it has something valuable to say, meaning most people will create content 2 or 3 times a week.
A good way to decide whether to post is to ask yourself “Would I be unhappy if a random person only ever saw this post from me?” If you wouldn’t be unhappy, post it. If you would be, perhaps leave it or bin it. This means we post roughly half as much, but we have never felt we’ve missed out on anything.
We think that you should let the format of your post decide how often you post. On X, a post can be up to 280 characters long, meaning that one clear idea can be included within the post. As a result, we can’t expect to have many ideas that are worth 280 characters in a given week. Some weeks we might post 4, and others we post none. During these weeks, we respond to other people’s posts but don’t post. However, we don’t feel this harms the account. If anything, people seem more willing to engage with accounts that are occasionally quiet.
Where the argument stops
Everyone is different. If you are providing news, people expect you to post daily (and frequently during events). If you provide customer service via X, it makes sense that you respond to customers when they message. If you enjoy posting daily and never struggle for content, we don’t mind! We are simply arguing with the rule itself, and the feelings of guilt it causes in people for whom it wasn’t intended.
| If you are | Our view |
|---|---|
| A news account | Post daily, more during events |
| A support account | Answer whenever customers write |
| Someone who enjoys daily posting | Carry on |
| A small business or an individual with a day job | Reply most days, publish 2 or 3 times a week |
| A new account | Replies first, posts second |
Conclusion
Be visible on most days, but only create content when you have something to say. Rather than worrying about whether you posted in the past 10 days, we recommend considering whether the past 10 posts were good. We expect that some people may disagree with us, and we would love to hear your opinions! Just don’t message us daily.
